The Torah Podcast

Cours de Torah — disponibles sur vos plateformes favorites

La force ne crée pas d'adhésion - avec le Rav Avraham Lemmel

La force ne crée pas d'adhésion - avec le Rav Avraham Lemmel

Avraham Lemmel ·

Am Israël & Actualité Moussar
Vitesse :

La force ne crée pas d'adhésion - avec le Rav Avraham Lemmel

Extrait du cours

Second, and this is the biggest problem , is that using force will never create genuine commitment from people. The only result you'll ever get is submission. "Fine, you're stronger, I accept." But deep down, my one and only dream is to say, "The day I can put you in your place, you'll see how I do it." The day I can cast you aside, I will, and with the greatest pleasure. Because for now, today, you hold the cards. Well , you hold the cards, you have to accept that, right? You're the strongest, you have the money, you have the power, you impose, no problem. But at no point will I subscribe to your concept, no. I will never subscribe to your values.

Lire la transcription complète ↓

Transcription479 mots

Transcription automatique — peut contenir des erreurs.

Second, and this is the biggest problem , is that using force will never create genuine commitment from people. The only result you'll ever get is submission. "Fine, you're stronger, I accept." But deep down, my one and only dream is to say, "The day I can put you in your place, you'll see how I do it." The day I can cast you aside, I will, and with the greatest pleasure. Because for now, today, you hold the cards.

Well , you hold the cards, you have to accept that, right? You're the strongest, you have the money, you have the power, you impose, no problem. But at no point will I subscribe to your concept, no. I will never subscribe to your values.

Because you managed to transmit these values to me through force. They will, in fact, create a form of opposition within me. Because we never like being forced. We never like being subjected to others as human beings.

Fundamentally, a human being wants to be free. Now, that’s a whole series of discussions on what freedom actually means. But basically, you want to be free. And since you want to be free, then what happens?

You think about how anyone who dares touch my freedom becomes an enemy. And since they become an enemy, the day I can get rid of them, I will do so very quickly. And so, your force will never succeed in creating commitment. A child cannot embrace values that you have imposed on them by force.

A marriage will never last if, quite simply, one of the two spouses uses the argument of force. You won't be able to create love that way. And the day they can break free, they will leave. You'll notice, by the way, that in a few weeks, we'll tell the story of Jacob and his children, and the text, coincidentally, speaks of Jacob and his brothers.

I heard from my father, he always says that here Jacob seeks to transmit, and since he seeks to transmit, what happens ? He calls his children "my brothers." What is the difference between a brother and a...With a brother, there is no superiority. If you want to convince someone, it's better that you be convinced yourself. It's better that you speak to him while being convinced deep down inside yourself.

You say do this because I believe in it, because you are my brother, because I care for you, because I am pained, because I want to. I can't tell him do this because I decided so. Who are you? Are you my father?

It's interesting to see that when Jacob wants to pass on a message to his children, he calls them my brothers, he no longer calls them my sons. Because he knows that the argument of force cannot be an argument for transmission.