The Torah Podcast

Cours de Torah — disponibles sur vos plateformes favorites

Daf hayomi BEKHOROT page 33

Daf hayomi BEKHOROT page 33

Rav Chemouny Benyamin ·

Daf Hayomi
Vitesse :

Abonnez-vous à la chaîne YouTube du Centre Rachi pour rester informé des derniers contenus originaux. Rejoignez-nous sur notre groupe facebook : https://www.facebook.com/groups/712826445437581/ Visitez le site du Centre Rachi : http://www.centrerachi.com/ Devenez le parrain de nos activités pour continuer le développement de nos projets Torah et faire grandir toujours le nom de D… Merci à vous et que Hashem puisse vous le rendre dans le domaine que vous désirez !  http://www.centrerachi.com/index.php/dons/

Extrait du cours

what if now the Cohen, the, the firstborn has a defect, okay? When it has a defect, we don't give it to the Cohen anymore. The owner keeps it at his place. Well, he's now having a barbecue meal at his place. Can he invite Cohen, Mr. Cohen, or is that not done? That is the subject. No. >> Wait, can I ask you a question before we continue? >> Sure. >> Does it still have the right to have the Pidyon HaBen on the Cohen a month later , no? For the newborn. >> Not a human newborn, a cow. Firstborn cow, sorry, I didn't specify Isaac, it's true. >> I've been gone for 6 months. >> Firstborn cow, sheep, it's born a firstborn.

Lire la transcription complète ↓

Transcription2034 mots

Transcription automatique — peut contenir des erreurs.

what if now the Cohen, the, the firstborn has a defect, okay? When it has a defect, we don't give it to the Cohen anymore. The owner keeps it at his place. Well, he's now having a barbecue meal at his place.

Can he invite Cohen, Mr. Cohen, or is that not done? That is the subject. No.

>> Wait, can I ask you a question before we continue? >> Sure. >> Does it still have the right to have the Pidyon HaBen on the Cohen a month later , no? For the newborn.

>> Not a human newborn, a cow. Firstborn cow, sorry, I didn't specify Isaac, it's true. >> I've been gone for 6 months. >> Firstborn cow, sheep, it's born a firstborn.

It's supposed to go to the Cohen. But it had a defect. When there is a defect, there is no need to give it to the Cohen. But can I invite the Cohen, or is that considered taunting him, let's put it that way?

>> I invite the Cohen but I warn him that it's meat that he shouldn't eat. >> So it says you can't. All or nothing, we've seen. Beth Hillel says even a non-Jew.

These are the details we'll have to understand this morning. Beth Hillel, the first line. When it is whole, only the Cohen eats it . But if it has a defect, it's clearly written in the Torah who can eat it, impure or pure, meaning there is no more Cohen, it has lost its holiness.

So of course he can eat. When it's impure, but that could be an impure Cohen, right? Who said that it's even a stranger who can eat? Beth Hillel says no, we are talking about a stranger who can eat it, and you'll even see later on, even a non-Jew Rabbi Akiva says not at all, it becomes completely normal meat.

When it loses its status, then you can have a meal and invite everyone, whether it be your Christian or Muslim neighbor when you live in Saint-Denis, or in England, or anywhere in Europe. There you go. Ah, you can invite them. There you go, you see you're here today Well, the Gemara says this source is not good for the [halacha] because the stag and the deer, there is no firstborn.

Yeah, they're wild, they're wild animals So listen closely to this subject. I studied this a bit yesterday or the day before regarding that story in the Parasha about Rachel sitting on the camel, stealing the idols, and telling her father I am in the time, ah, I studied the source, here it is, it's the He says that back then, when a woman was [menstruating], she was completely in a separate tent, and people didn't even want to speak with her back then because they were afraid of the, of the, of the negative energy. Okay? I found that among the Ethiopians when I officiated a few Ethiopian weddings.

There are Ethiopians who told me that back home in Ethiopia, there were huts outside the city for women. Well, that’s not the subject, but now, the question is, can a woman eat the meat of the firstborn? A. Okay?

The topic is incredible. So, uh 13 Regarding the Niddah, Beit Shammai says she does not eat, the woman there, a Kohen's wife, let's say, okay, even if He says it's like sacred meat in the Temple. A Niddah woman there, even if her name is Mrs. Cohen, can she eat it?

No. So here too, no. Beit Hillel said if it’s intact, then maybe Mrs. Cohen cannot, but if it now has a blemish, and just as you can invite Christian and Mohamed, you can of course, she can sit at the table, ma'am , when she is a Niddah.

Beit Shammai disagrees; he says there is an impurity, uh, what do you call it when someone touches a grave or steps on an insect, it's an external impurity, and there is an internal impurity. Niddah is the body itself releasing an impurity, okay? If you want to look a bit into Kabbalah, Niddah means that something died, which came out of the woman's body, a potential for life that did not develop. Yeah, not today, because today we are all impure, right?

It is where we saw this difference in the Paschal lamb. The Paschal lamb, people who were in a cemetery had the right to eat it, but not people who had an impurity coming out of their body. What are the examples? Niddah, Zav, all seminal emissions, lepers, uh, a woman who gave birth, everything that had something that had contact with death, even lepers and all that, it's cells in the body that died, all of that.

>> says it's not the same. In the Paschal lamb, it is clearly specified. For us, it's just marked as general impurity. Well, Now that we've talked about the meat and that we are allowed to eat it once it has lost its firstborn status, how do we do it?

In the same way that we, we skin, what do you call removing the hide there? Flaying, skinning, no? >> Skinning. >> Removing the hide.

>> Well, yeah, I got two, two words, that's good. Well, so one of the two, there you go, or both, so I'm at shalom with you. Uh We don't have the right to do it from head to toe in a normal way, right, because So we do it in a different way. And it says it's the same for a firstborn that lost its status.

You must not remove the hide in the same way as a normal animal. You still have to, uh, signify that it was a firstborn, that it lost its status So we change the way we, we process it a little. Who is this rabbi who said that? Why?

What's the matter? It's the same one who said that a woman doesn't eat it. That means it lost its status but it's still called, okay? So it had to go for the It's the same for sacred meat in the temple, that it shouldn't be skinned or flayed in the same way.

Yes. >> So, if there were, there were two, two expiatory sacrifices, one that is complete and one that has a defect, then we sacrifice the complete one of course , and the other one that has a defect, uh, we sell it, recover the money to make shofars, okay, for the, the maintenance of the synagogue. If meanwhile they hadn't, they discovered the defect only after they had performed the, so it depends. If the, the blood has been sprinkled, we can eat.

If the blood has not been sprinkled, we eat it Oh, I see the rest of the comments. No, even if the meat is already in the pot, we can't eat it because it had a defect. So why there does he authorize eating the meat of, to the people who are, etcetera. Say the same rule as you said in the sacrifice over there, that as soon as it has a defect, well, we can't eat it anymore.

It says it's not the same because over there we can't, we can't in a firstborn , we can't exchange it. Ah, we can't, uh, walk around, it's the If it's not good, but in a sacrifice, if it's not good, we can always exchange it for another. We saw that on page 31. The sacrifices that went wrong, let's say, where they had a defect, we can sell them by the kilo and the profit goes to the temple.

Yeah, of course. To everyone. After that, it no longer has it, it has completely lost its status. But not in the Even if there is a profit in the skin and not in the meat, In the end, they forbade doing that because there could be exchanges in the sacred meat.

If you allow it to be exchanged, then he could build up herds, he could do business with it. So, we avoid it. One more small topic for today. Back then, people often went to the doctor once a month, I think, even once a week to draw blood.

>> Yeah. >> Blood draw, but without analysis, eh, just to renew the blood. Apparently, they even did that to animals. There were professions like that back then, eh, rabbis whose job it was.

Uh, people >> That. >> No, no, it's for health. So, if now there is There is a firstborn and the veterinarian or the doctor sees that he needs to have blood drawn. Now, there is a risk.

If we draw blood, it could become handicapped and thus lose its status. Do I have the right to get involved or not? Look at how many subjects there can be on each one. It's incredible.

So, the Rabbi Judah says don't touch it, even if it's dying. >> They say and you will see in the, there is a possibility, you have to be an expert to draw blood without making it handicapped. If he did it anyway and he didn't know, he already did the blood draw and now it turns out he created a defect. Can we do the now or is it an open door for schemes?

Eh, someone will say, well, instead of giving it to Mr. Cohen, I'll draw its blood and then I'll do the says it's fine. Second opinion, no. We still have 2 minutes.

We bring the same but with another opinion, it's It's the same subject in a barrel of. What's the story there? There was a barrel of apples or I don't know what, or wine, that was meant for the Cohen. And there was a doubt, maybe an insect touched it or someone who is impure.

There is a doubt, what do we do? Or it depends where it is. If we put it outside, it's strange. So go inside there.

Joshua says the opposite. If it was inside where it was covered, you have to uncover it and take it outside. That means it's definitely no good. Third opinion.

Don't touch it. So each one is, these are three rabbis who have the subject here, they are the same three rabbis who have the subject over there. >> The law says it's not the same subject. Over there, nobody did anything.

You think someone touched it, but here, you're definitely going to do a blood test. You're going to do it with your hands there. It's not the same subject. Over there, we can wait for an opinion that will tell us, or cameras that will discover if the barrel touched someone.

But here, we can't know anything. What is he going to tell you? Do the blood test or not, we don't know the consequences. Do you see the comparison a little bit?

We could stay on this subject for a week. And each one has their source. We have the same subject in the, we have the same subject with castrating animals So the whole subject is when there is already a defect and he wants to add another defect. He wants to castrate it Is the fact that it's already handicapped the end of it, or do you have the right to castrate someone who already has a defect?

>> For what purpose? >> What? To castrate it? I don't know, it's sick, it has something, you have to remove the >> The illness.

To be able to save it already. It also depends on if it was born with a defect or not. The fact that we aren't allowed to touch them, so don't do it, don't intervene at all with the animals. If it has a problem now in its ear, we can bring it to, uh, back then we would put a little paste and like that, the dog will come and bite it, and that way it's the dog that caused the defect and not you.

Well, that's for the next page.