
Daf hayomi BEKHOROT page 30
Abonnez-vous à la chaîne YouTube du Centre Rachi pour rester informé des derniers contenus originaux. Rejoignez-nous sur notre groupe facebook : https://www.facebook.com/groups/712826445437581/ Visitez le site du Centre Rachi : http://www.centrerachi.com/ Devenez le parrain de nos activités pour continuer le développement de nos projets Torah et faire grandir toujours le nom de D… Merci à vous et que Hashem puisse vous le rendre dans le domaine que vous désirez ! http://www.centrerachi.com/index.php/dons/
Extrait du cours
Yesterday we saw in the Mishna that some people were sometimes not honest and they didn't calculate, let's say, the Shmita or the tithes. Were we allowed to buy from them? So we saw that there was even an issue with oil, olive oil that wasn't tithed, and so on. So we are looking at a story. First line, page 30. There was a butcher who was selling the fat that is next to the kidneys of the animals, of the cows. And if there is fat that is permitted in the cow, there is also a part that must have the nerves removed, right? >> Hmm.
Transcription1980 mots
Transcription automatique — peut contenir des erreurs.
Yesterday we saw in the Mishna that some people were sometimes not honest and they didn't calculate, let's say, the Shmita or the tithes. Were we allowed to buy from them? So we saw that there was even an issue with oil, olive oil that wasn't tithed, and so on. So we are looking at a story.
First line, page 30. There was a butcher who was selling the fat that is next to the kidneys of the animals, of the cows. And if there is fat that is permitted in the cow, there is also a part that must have the nerves removed, right? >> Hmm.
>> And we don't know if the butcher is kosher or not; back then, there were no certifications. So When they said there was a problem, the Rabbi said he can't even sell nuts because we don't trust him. According to Rabbi Judah, even water and salt, he's not allowed, because with nuts, there is also an issue. With nuts , you have to tithe.
He said no, because in those days it was common for butchers to also sell nuts along with the meat. So if you authorize that, he might go back to selling the non-kosher item, so we forbade it completely. That was yesterday's subject. New subject for today, Mishna line 7.
If someone doesn't calculate the Shmita , does that mean they don't count God in these matters, or just about the Shmita ? So the Gemara says the seventh year has nothing to do with the tithes. Meaning, all year long you can believe him when you ask if it's been tithed, even when you ask, "Generally, has the required amount been tithed?" If he tells you yes, you trust him, even though he doesn't observe the... Sometimes someone doesn't do the tithes , but...
He does it by heart. So that exists. It exists that people are more religious in one area and not in another. Bravo.
If someone doesn't calculate the tithes either, then we don't even know if everything he touches is pure or impure. On the other hand, there is someone who sometimes doesn't calculate purity but respects the tithes. In short, what do we learn from this? That is what we are learning today.
It is a very beautiful subject. It doesn't mean anything if someone didn't, or even someone who did. It doesn't mean that if you don't do one thing, you don't do another. That's the rule.
Why did we already talk about the difference between the tithes and the ...The...is for the whole land of Israel . That the tithes, in principle, had to be eaten in Jerusalem, the tithes of the fourth year. So perhaps, uh, for Jerusalem he is less strict. So that is why there are differences.
And besides, the... they could not be exchanged. But the... we can exchange them for money.
So every subject has its advantages and disadvantages. >> And both are from the Torah: the tithe and the...whether purity or impurity, they are... Well then, if he is respectful of the rules of impurity, in principle, isn't it certain that he is respectful in everything else? Because if he already respects a subject that is not of the Torah, doesn't that carry over to the other?
You're right, but if we saw at home that he doesn't respect it, it doesn't mean that outside... Does the fact that he doesn't respect two subjects in the same field, that is , regarding fruits, mean he also doesn't in other subjects? That is our subject. So this is...who judges for the good and says that even if he doesn't respect one area, even if it is in the same field, you know, we are talking about fruits, it's not serious.
But they say no, if it's in fruits, in all fruit-related matters, be careful. Rabbi Judah was stricter because there was a story involving him. Someone mocked his neighbor, saying to him, "It shows you are a convert and the son of a convert." That means that on the mocking side, you don't know the rules. He said, "Oh, why do you tell me that?" So it is...who is even stricter.
He says no, if you don't do something, it means that >> You don't do everything. >> you don't do everything. All or nothing . Everyone has their own path.
We could give entire lessons. Rabbi, we even have this in our personalities, some are like that, we all are, no? There are people for whom it's all or nothing. Meaning they can't, it's extreme.
Some are like that. Each with their own Turn the page. >> In the pool, that's why we put in a little water. >> Right.
That is the subject. Now we start telling the stories. From the Tanya. Line 3.
If someone knows nothing, meaning he has never studied anything, and the next day you see him with a—okay, let's say. Meaning overnight, is it a show or not a show? He says no, if you catch him doing something that isn't good, it's a show. No, why not?
Even if he made a mistake, it doesn't mean that everything is false . Wow, we have the same subject regarding converts. This is a very well-known one A convert finishes, and you see him the next day having committed a sin. Has the conversion fallen through?
Because he didn't respect something from the law or not. What is it? The conversion is valid. But there are many strict ones who are afraid of that.
So they won't convert him. That too is a major subject. If he converts before failing, he says " I accept everything except Shabbat," we can't be fooled, we agree on that. A Jewish man who accepts everything except one single thing, we cannot accept him.
Even if it's not Shabbat, even if it's just a small detail, there you go. Now, whether he does everything afterwards or not is another subject, but at least before failing, he must accept everything. A Cohen or a Levi back in the day comes and says, "Listen, I can do everything, but I can't touch the blood or anything ." A Levi says, "I can do everything, but I don't like music." No, no, sir, all or Look a bit at the examples we are about to give right now. I am on line 14-15.
Someone who wants to become wise must show that he applies that wisdom at home as well. This means if he decides now, starting today, I don't know, I'll wear a kippah , then he should wear it at home just as he does in the street, because if he wears it only in the street and not at home, it's still... Afterward he says no, not at all, let him be, let him be, if he wants to wear the kippah only outside, don't look at what he does at home. Little by little, he will do it at home too.
If someone decides to be pure, "Okay, I'm going to the mikvah every day and all," he must first start doing well, okay, before he does the whole body. Now, if we’ve seen that he’s not doing well, can I cancel his mikvah membership ? Because anyway, there is an opinion. Yes.
So, there are those who say yes, and there are those who say no. Of course, right. It’s always a good path. How long does he need to be in the trial period?
Meaning, how long do I need to see that he respects it? If it’s for the water mikvah, for impurity, 30 days. But for everything that is the impurities of not stepping on insects and all that back then, a one-year test. Beit Hillel says it’s one year so that he has also adopted the rule.
Meaning, it’s someone adopting a good habit, if you like. After one year, it means he is established. But what does the Gemara say? Beit Hillel is strict here, right?
One year, why not mine? You’re right, no, mistake. Beit Hillel says one month for both. Let’s continue.
If someone commits to things back then, they are matters of wisdom, but they aren't things written in the Torah, it's not Shabbat. What do we call that? A >> Behavior. >> a behavior where he wants to be more strict in a certain area.
Now, he wants from now on, I’ll take a simple example , right? that blue one there with the blue thread So, back then, how did one make a commitment? You have to grab three sages and say in front of them "I commit," and then he has to keep his word and everything we saw. But if it’s someone from his family, his children, his wife, there’s no need to bring three sages.
If he made the commitment, does it also commit his whole family now, his children or not? There are two opinions , right? One says no, the children must also commit themselves in front of three people. Second opinion says the children are in the same package.
If he committed that my whole household now, uh, they will, I don't know what >> If he committed that my whole household now, uh, they will, I don't know what, as an example, very well. the Roman era Once they had a subject they didn't understand, they sent the question to Rabbi Hanina. And he was a Cohen, uh, line 32. >> Sorry, thank you.
>> So he had pure fruits, he said sit down It felt like a lack of respect because he said "sit on the fruits," and they didn't understand, they didn't understand how he, in quotes, disrespected those people. No, because they were holy, healthy fruits, and he wanted the rabbis, since he knew they were pure people, he wanted them to keep them. That's the example of Techelet. If there was a place that sold blue for tzitzit and the father passed away, we still trust the family to continue in the same, in the same field unless we find a problem.
Meaning, if the next day we arrive and see it's not the real blue, then hop, we stop trusting. A woman who was married to someone who was wise and she became a widow or divorced. So now, how does she handle the customs she had from her ex-husband? Uh, is she obligated to adapt to the new husband?
He says no, no, I don't do those strict things. Or does she have the right to keep her previous ones? So if she wants to keep the old ones, she must talk, discuss, and agree on it before the marriage. But poor thing, if she married someone who knows nothing, now it's the opposite , it's not the same, and she wants to keep a little of the, the thing.
So does that remain automatic or not? Two opinions. Last story for today. Listen to this story.
There was a woman who was married to someone and she was used to tying his—meaning she helped him , or I don't know why, she wanted to do it every morning. And then he, he passed away. And after that, she and the other one—I don't know if he wore them—but she tied the threads for the packages, you see. It means she, she, she kept, she kept the same trade, there you go, but one was for the, and one for the...that's today's page, tomorrow we'll finish the chapter.
I find the subject really beautiful, look at how many consequences there are Summary. Someone who is wise in one area , it doesn't mean that in others—it's not all or nothing in the Torah. Everything you do is good.



